Ideas from The Emerald Standard
The First-Time Visitor Walkthrough
By Jim Kukral, author of The Emerald Standard
Published
This walkthrough is my own application of the ideas in The Emerald Standard. It is not a description of documented Cleveland Metroparks practice or policy.
The easiest way to see your institution the way the public sees it is to arrive like a stranger. Pick a park, branch library, station or office you run, choose a day you are not expected, and walk it from the moment you park to the moment you reach the thing people came for. Bring a notebook. Write down every moment you hesitate.
Here is the route, step by step, with what to look for at each stop.
1. The parking lot
The visit starts before anyone gets out of the car. Is it obvious where to turn in? Are spaces marked, and are accessible spaces close to the entrance? Is the lot lit if people arrive early or leave late? Is there trash on the ground? A visitor decides how careful to be, and how welcome they are, in this first minute.
2. Finding the way
Stand where a visitor gets out of the car and look around. Can you tell where to go without asking? Signs should be legible from a distance, in plain words, and placed where the decision happens, not after it. Check them for fading, damage and outdated names. If the sign says one thing and the map says another, the visitor will trust neither.
3. The entrance
An entrance should answer three questions immediately: am I in the right place, is it open, and am I allowed in? Hours should be posted and accurate. Doors and gates should be easy to open for someone carrying a child, pushing a stroller or using a wheelchair. Notice the tone of every posted notice. A wall of rules written as warnings tells the guest they are a suspect, not a guest.
4. Restrooms
Restrooms are where many people make up their minds about a public place. Can a first-time visitor find them without asking? Are they open during posted hours, stocked and clean? Is there a way to report a problem? If you would not use it yourself, a guest will remember that long after they forget anything else about the visit.
5. Who can help
Somewhere along the walk, a visitor will have a question. Ask yourself who they would ask. Is there a person, a clearly marked desk, or a posted number? Are staff easy to recognize? When you ask a question yourself, notice whether the answer comes with a direction and a smile or with a shrug. The book's view is that every person on staff is part of the guest experience, not only the ones with customer-facing titles.
6. The destination
Finally, reach the trail, the shelf, the platform or the counter people came for. Does it deliver what the signs and the website promised? Is there a moment that makes a first-time visitor glad they came? Then walk back to the car and see whether the route out is as clear as the route in.
What to do with your notes
Sort every hesitation you wrote down into three groups:
- Fix this week: burned-out lights, missing signs, closed restrooms, trash.
- Fix this year: confusing layouts, unclear entrances, outdated maps and wording.
- Decide as leaders: what every guest deserves here, and the floor you will not let the experience fall below.
Repeat the walk regularly, at different times and in different weather, and invite staff from other departments to do it too. Most of what you find will not need a bigger budget. It will need someone deciding that good enough is not the standard.